In the realm of vinyl playback, the choice of cartridge plays a pivotal role in determining the overall sound quality and listening experience. Two highly regarded contenders in the market are the Audio-Technica AT95E and AT-VM95E. This comprehensive comparison aims to delve into the intricacies of these cartridges, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and suitability for different audiophile needs.

Stylus Design

The AT95E utilizes a conical stylus, while the AT-VM95E employs a nude elliptical stylus. Conical styli are known for their durability and ability to track warped records effectively. However, they may not extract as much detail from the grooves as elliptical styli.

On the other hand, elliptical styli offer a more precise contact with the record, resulting in improved tracking and retrieval of high-frequency information. They are more susceptible to damage, though, and may require more frequent replacement.

Frequency Response

The AT95E has a frequency response of 20 Hz to 20 kHz, while the AT-VM95E boasts a wider range of 15 Hz to 25 kHz. This extended frequency response in the AT-VM95E allows for a more accurate reproduction of the full spectrum of audio, including subtle nuances and deep bass notes.

Tracking Ability

The AT95E has a tracking force of 1.5 to 2.5 grams, making it suitable for a wide range of tonearms. The AT-VM95E, with its tracking force of 1.8 to 2.2 grams, may be a better choice for higher-compliance tonearms.

Both cartridges exhibit excellent tracking ability, minimizing distortion and ensuring a smooth and engaging listening experience.

Output Level

The AT95E produces an output level of 3.5 mV, while the AT-VM95E generates a slightly higher output of 4.0 mV. A higher output level can be advantageous in systems with lower-gain phono stages or preamps, as it provides a stronger signal for amplification.

Compliance

The AT95E has a compliance of 15 µm/mN, while the AT-VM95E has a compliance of 10 µm/mN. Compliance refers to the cartridge’s ability to move freely in response to the record’s grooves.

A higher compliance cartridge is more suitable for lower-mass tonearms, as it can track more accurately and minimize resonance. The AT-VM95E’s lower compliance makes it a better match for heavier tonearms.

Sound Quality

The AT95E is known for its balanced and neutral sound signature, with a warm and inviting midrange. It excels at reproducing vocals and instruments with clarity and detail.

The AT-VM95E, on the other hand, offers a more extended and dynamic soundstage. It delivers a punchy and controlled bass response, with excellent separation and imaging. The treble is crisp and airy, providing a detailed and spacious listening experience.

Suitability for Different Systems

The AT95E is a versatile cartridge that can complement a wide range of systems. Its affordability and durability make it a popular choice for entry-level audiophiles or those looking for a reliable and budget-friendly option.

The AT-VM95E is better suited for mid- to high-end systems, where it can fully showcase its sonic capabilities. Its higher output level and extended frequency response make it an ideal choice for demanding audiophiles seeking the ultimate vinyl playback experience.

Takeaways: Deciding the Victor

Choosing between the Audio-Technica AT95E and AT-VM95E ultimately depends on the individual’s audiophile preferences and system setup. The AT95E offers a balanced and affordable option, while the AT-VM95E provides a more extended and dynamic sound signature.

For those seeking a versatile and budget-friendly cartridge, the AT95E is an excellent choice. For audiophiles seeking the highest possible sound quality, the AT-VM95E is the preferred option.

What People Want to Know

Q: Which cartridge has a better tracking ability?
A: Both cartridges offer excellent tracking ability, but the AT-VM95E may have a slight edge due to its nude elliptical stylus.

Q: Is the AT95E compatible with all tonearms?
A: Yes, the AT95E’s tracking force range makes it suitable for a wide range of tonearms.

Q: How often should I replace the stylus on the AT-VM95E?
A: The stylus on the AT-VM95E should be replaced every 1,000 to 1,500 hours of use, depending on usage and record condition.

Q: Can I use the AT95E on a high-end turntable?
A: While the AT95E can be used on high-end turntables, it may not fully exploit their capabilities. The AT-VM95E is a better choice for such systems.

Q: Which cartridge is better for playing classical music?
A: Both cartridges can handle classical music well, but the AT-VM95E’s extended frequency response and dynamic soundstage may be more suitable for capturing the nuances and grandeur of classical recordings.